Student Contribution: On Hand Washing Posted by
A Primer on the Washing of the Hands (Netilat Yadayim) - by Larry Cohen
I have recently begun reading a very interesting book recently published in English by Artscroll. It is the first of a five-volume set containing the Kitzur Shulchan Aruch with differing interpretations to and rulings of Mishna Berura and Igros Moshe. Other sources are delved into as well. I had become interested in source material for Halacha through the inspiration provided by Rabbi Fink in his classes on Halacha. Concurrent with this renewed interest I answered Artscroll’s advertisement for this book. While it does go into many other sources for rulings, it will not make me a giant in this subject — perhaps a pigmy? I would recommend this series for as it is in Hebrew, and Hebrew Interpolated with the English as well. Volume 2 is scheduled to come out in July.
Many of us (including myself) have learned hand washing from others (through observation). I have never seen a course offered in this subject or even publically discussed at all. What we learned to do through observation and/or instruction has become routine. I started reading the above referenced book and found it to be an eye opener on this subject. I would like to share with you some of the concepts that were a surprise to me.
While hand washing upon rising in the morning is Rabbinic in nature; there is an allusion to it in Tehillim 26:6-7. “I will wash in cleanliness my hands …” A spirit of impurity leaves your body after awakening — except for your fingers. Washing of the hands (really the fingers) in the prescribed manner without a blessing removes the impurity. However, it is considered proper to wash the hands until the wrist.
Now, what is the proscribed procedure? “One takes the utensil filled with water with his right hand and transfers it to his left hand. He then pours the water first onto his right hand. After this he takes the utensil filled with water with his right hand and pours the water onto his left hand. He should do this (in alternating fashion) three times.”
Where should the water go from the hand washing? One must keep in mind that the water is impure. It should not be used to water animals, wash the floor, wash dishes, or thrown onto an area where people will walk so as they do not become contaminated by the impurity in the water. It should simply be poured down the drain or an open area that is not walked on.
Before washing, one must be careful not to touch an orifice of the body (mouth, nostrils, eyes, eyelids, ears, rectum), or food. If food is touched before washing then the food must be rinsed off three times.
The amount of water used should equal at least a revi’it (between 2.9 and 5.1 oz.), not discolored, be applied through human force (i.e., not from the faucet directly over the hands but from a utensil).
After you clean yourself and have attended to your needs (urination, etc.) you return again to perform the hand washing a second time and with the standard blessing. Some hold that the second washing should be done just prior to when you begin davening.
There are many activities during the day that require hand washing. A few are: arising from a bed, leaving a lavatory, cutting nails or hair, marital relations, scratching the head, etc. The Mishna Berura specifically states “having impurities (ruach ra) on his hands does not prohibit him from praying or studying Torah. Thus, one who does not have water (without which the ruach ra will not be removed), can clean his hands with any material and pray; later, when he obtains water he must wash his hands with water to remove the ruach ra.”
I would be remiss if I did not address Chabad. Undoubtedly some of you noticed that Chabad conducts hand washing differently than described above. To understand how Chabad has changed from the Mishna Berura, one needs to consult the Shulchan HaRav — not a very large book.
There are other important details that I have not included. I hope this short essay sparks the reader’s interest to investigate further.
Tags: Artscroll, Hand washing, Shulchan Aruch, Shulchan Harav, Student Contribution
Larry Cohen
Larry Cohen grew up in Fall River, Massachusetts – a highly anti-semitic city at that time. Subjected to weekly physical attacks he learned early-on to band with the Jewish Community. Larry graduated with a BS in Physics from Worcester Polytechnic Institute (a school that limited Jewish enrollment to 10%), and Thomas Jefferson School of Law in San Diego. On the Jewish side Larry attended HaMivtar for a year studying under and inspired by Rabbis Chaim Brovender, Avi Weinstein, and Stu Felix, among others. His work experience has been IBM, US Department of Defense, and a private law practice (from age 14 until 22, Larry played piano professionally). He also worked for U.S. Intelligence. On a personal note, Larry Cohen has five children and six grandchildren. As he says himself, “The happiness in my life and the realization of my dreams I owe to my wife, Elisheva (Linda)”.
interesting topic. I just studied a little on this. On the issue of when one says the netilat yadayim before eating, see Biur Halakha on Shulchan Arukh Orach Chayim Hilkhot Netilat Yadayim, 158:11.
If I read it correctly, it says that Rambam, Or Zarua, and Karo (in the S.A. and Beit Yosef) all agree that one may say the brakha before washing, but Rabbenu Tam and the Tur says first wash, then bless. Biur Halakha’s conclusion is that is one does not stop another from blessing then washing but if one does so, make sure your hands are clean.
The overall problem with netillat yadaim is that it does not clean the hands or sanitize hands or fingers. It is a symbolic act for praise of G-d. Real cleaning must be done with soap and an antiseptic. Before handling food this is most important.
The last point about Chabad and Shulchan Aruch HaRav is unclear.
What are the differences in practice regarding Netilas Yadayim Shachrit which we “undoubtedly” have seen?
The point of Chabad departing from the Mishna Berurah is ahistorical. The Mishnah Berurah often cites the Shulchan Aruch HaRav who preceded him. Poskim of a similar era often respectfully disagree, as we see the Aruch HaShulchan differs at times with the Mishnah Berura.
Please clarify.
Thank you.